The bitter contract dispute surrounding Smart Chisanupong and the future of Top Form’s SmartBoom partnership has escalated dramatically. After our last report, Grand Ivory Records (GIR) dropped two bombshell statements—one addressing alleged privacy violations against Smart and another attempting to clarify the contract dispute with Headliner TH and WeTV.
However, instead of calming tensions, these announcements have raised more questions about Smart’s career, the fate of Top Form Season 2, and whether the beloved SmartBoom pairing can survive.
Here’s a detailed breakdown of the latest developments—and what they mean for fans, the industry, and Smart himself.
1. Grand Ivory’s Privacy Warning: A Disturbing New Layer
On June 15, 2025, GIR issued a strongly worded statement condemning fan harassment toward Smart. The company accused certain individuals of:
- Stalking Smart in private spaces (residences, personal locations)
- Monitoring him outside official schedules
- Recording & spreading unauthorized content
The statement emphasized that such actions violate privacy laws (including Thailand’s PDPA) and warned of legal action if the behavior continues.
Why This Matters:
- Fan Backlash Risk: While some fans support Smart’s independence, others may see this as GIR deflecting blame amid the contract dispute.
- Mental Health Concerns: If true, these incidents could explain Smart’s recent withdrawal from events—but GIR’s timing raises eyebrows.
- Industry Impact: This could set a new precedent for how agencies handle artist safety in Thailand’s intense BL fandom culture.
2. GIR’s Contract Clarification: Contradictions & Unanswered Questions
In a second statement, GIR finally addressed the SmartBoom breakup controversy—but their explanations conflict with earlier claims from WeTV and Tailai Entertainment.
Key Claims from GIR:
Smart Was Always Under GIR’s Primary Management
- They signed him in 2020 and trained him in singing, acting, and performance.
- A special agreement with Headliner TH only covered Top Form-related activities.
Mini-Album Plans Were Paused for Top Form
- Smart was 70% done with a solo mini-album before Top Form’s casting.
- GIR halted the project to let him focus on the series.
They Deny Refusing SmartBoom Work
- GIR strongly denies blocking Smart from CP activities.
- Claims Headliner TH mismanaged Smart’s rights.
New Agreement in the Works
- GIR is negotiating a fresh deal with Headliner TH to continue SmartBoom.
- International appearances are already planned through October 2025.
Contradictions & Unresolved Issues:
WeTV’s Previous Allegations:
- WeTV accused GIR of unilaterally terminating their contract.
- Claimed Smart refused SmartBoom events, including a June 1 livestream.
Smart’s Silence:
- Smart has not personally confirmed GIR’s version of events.
- Fans question: Is he being controlled, or is this his choice?
Top Form Season 2 Uncertainty:
- If Smart’s involvement remains unstable, recasting or rewriting may be necessary.
3. What’s Next for SmartBoom & Top Form?
Possible Outcomes:
Reconciliation
- If GIR & Headliner TH finalize a new deal, SmartBoom could continue—but trust is damaged.
Legal War
- WeTV may sue for damages, freezing Smart’s solo career and delaying Season 2.
Smart Goes Solo
- If GIR fully pulls Smart from CP work, Boom may get a new partner—or Top Form could write Jin out.
Final Verdict: A Messy Battle with No Clear Winner
Grand Ivory’s statements addressed some concerns but failed to fully clarify the contract dispute. Meanwhile:
- Top Form’s future hangs in the balance.
- Smart’s career faces legal & reputational risks.
- Fans remain divided—and frustrated.
One thing is certain: This fight isn’t over yet.
Contract Dispute Recap → SmartBoom Breakup: Contract Clash Halts Top Form Duo
As reported in our initial breakdown, GIR’s sudden termination of the Headliner TH deal on May 12 triggered legal backlash…
